Showing posts with label Feminist Pedagogy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Feminist Pedagogy. Show all posts

20 October 2008

Response to Feminist Pedagogy

"Feminist Pedagogy" Response


Like the critical pedagogy essay before it, I had reservations about feminist pedagogy before even getting through the first page. I’m comfortable enough to say this had little to do with a bias against feminism itself, but by the “positioning” I felt a composition teacher would take on in this role. From my observations in life, in my family, and in the women I’ve dated, I’ve come to define a feminist is someone who analyzes the world through a lens of gender-awareness in our media, society, business, etc., with the idea of striving for equal rights for the sexes. While this is a worthwhile pursuit, I wondered how it could be equitable in a composition class, a place where I believed should remain a blank slate on stark perspectives. Just as critical pedagogy worked on the presumption of oppression of the public and using writing as a form of liberation, feminism generally works on the premise of a patriarchal-run society and values and uses writing to inspect and fight against these things. What if every student does not believe these things? And just as it was noted in both essays, statements such as these, regardless of veracity, can often create a backlash in the classroom, especially with the social connotations feminism brings up in our society. Someone will always get angry in a good composition class, but when the writing classroom gets politicized and/or genderized, I have know the benefits before I tap into such a pedagogy.


The idea that women and men write differently, I admit, is one I often try to ignore. There were always the sayings that women write prettier and keep diaries -- they are more expressive -- and that men write to solve problems -- they are achievement-oriented -- were there even in my grade school days. I always figured these archetypes would be balanced out in time, but the studies done on pages 122-123 seem to take these observations I had and exemplified them. These differences even reminded me of an study my old rhetoric professor did. He analyzed course catalogs from women’s private schools and compared them to those of mainstream colleges. He found that on average, the course catalogs were much more descriptive of the classes available; they expounded not only what the class was about and its goals, but how students’ lives could be enriched by them.


What really caught my eye in the “Writing (and Reading) . . . Differently” section was how gendered writing was assigned and reviewed. In trying to teach students to write “outside their boxes,” teachers forget they get caught up in their own paradigms of good writing. I really connected to Peterson’s grading of male narratives. Just like she could gain disgust at the beer commercial canoe trips, I would be hard on women’s writing that I felt was too flighty, too full of metaphors. I’d ask for a more “substantial” paper, something with some spine to it, some “ompf,” I’d say with a closed fist. I always wanted more them to bring up more counter arguments so they could counter them right back with hard evidence, not just bring up. But after reading this essay, I’ve begun to think that’s not the best case. I do like personal anecdotes in the beginnings of essays, but maybe I can accept them more as evidence in the future. I’m also the sort of teacher that wants students to create an argumentative essay almost right off the bat, but the essay’s given me plenty of evidence to consider exploratory essays.


As helpful as it can be to recognize a woman’s voice on paper and in the classroom, I found the critiques on logic as a masculine form of writing to be very disturbing. Feminist scholars look at the art of argument to be a masculine genre, and antagonistic and violent as well? Can they be really serious about not using these tools in critical writing? I understand that logic as we know it today was created by white men hundreds of years ago, but that doesn’t mean it necessarily favors them. The rules of geometry and calculus were laid out by men years ago as well, but no one would ever say these equation rules are sexist. For me, logos is exactly that -- sexless. And whether we like it or not, this is a world of conflicting beliefs and desires, and if we want to be taken seriously, we must understand what makes persuasive communication and argue our viewpoint effectively. Just bringing up personal experiences won’t cut it in most scenarios. I find it hard to believe that feminists such as Annas want women to write political essays to break out into public forums, but find that “masculine” logic (what is masculine logic, and how would it differ from feminine one?) and linear reasoning stifle the woman writer’s voice. They seem to see feminist writing as a form of consolidation between two forces, but proper logos-based writing does that as well. Logos doesn’t look for “who’s right” but finds the quality of reasoning and evidence for both points.


And as harsh as I am on this relatively small section on the essay, I must also recognize that I’m deeply entrenched in this line of thought. I was continuingly asking “What else is there, if not logic?” while reading this section, and I honestly couldn’t find an alternative. They mentioned that masculine reasoning in writing doesn’t allow for women’s expressive writing and making sense of the world, but that didn’t flesh out the answer as much as I would have liked. Perhaps feminists are advocating a more open-style of writing, where the thesis is more implicit. I would definitely like to read more of Catherine Lamb’s work to gain a greater understanding of feminist/Rogerian forms of mediation.


As well as questions, the essay has given me a few writing topics as well. I’m going to be teaching Image Analysis in two weeks, and I think looking at media with a gendered-lens fits very well with the chapter. One application idea I had was looking for “strong women” on television. What makes them strong in student eyes, how are they portrayed in relating to men, etc. This could work across many genres in television and bring up many questions in students. Why is it in sitcom-style shows, the man of the house is always the idiot, and the woman has to play the “straight man” (but almost always is beautiful)? How come in many sci-fi or high drama shows, women dealing with conflict means dealing with rape or pregnancy? I’m not sure whether to include male characters or not in this idea, as the traditional idea of a “strong man” is fairly concrete in our culture.


Besides writing topics, Feminist Pedagogy has given me my chosen research topic for this class. I got the idea while reading about how many feminist teachers try to keep the classroom work collaborative and student-student centered. Feminist pedagogy has different opinions of power structures on the class, often compromising on the idea of the teacher as coach, but not authoritarian. What really got my attention was the “Politics of Speaking” section. In thinking up ideas on how to get women to speak up more in class, I remember that women (and in general, men as well) would be much more animated in group discussions. Another issue I was grappling with at the time were revisions I did with students on their theses and main ideas on Summary/Strong Response papers. Too often their ideas would meander or their thesis would not be strong enough, regardless of gender. When they brought in their drafts to peer reviews, these issues would not be brought up, perhaps because they see the draft with an of authority.


The idea I came up with was this: Instead of enforcing the “masculine” autonomous writer right away, why not let brainstorming be a more collaborative ideal. My plan is to let students write notes on their main points and ideas for their assignments, get into groups of three, and have each person talk for ten minutes. The other group members may stay silent or ask questions and comments. The idea here is that speaking about their project will make their work more substantial to them, but also more malleable, as it’s easier to change one’s mind in discussion than to do so in writing. This may or may not be the “multivocal, relational writing process” discuss on page 124, but I’m still looking forward to seeing how it can strengthen beginning drafts of my student papers.


In the end, it’s hard to be against something that seems united in only the awareness that there’s distinct differences and expectations in gender in our society, and questions how we should go about it our composition studies. While I can understand why feminist pedagogy could be a minefield for some, I’m looking forward to applying some of its ideas in assignments of analysis and politics.

15 October 2008

I Cried in Class (and I Hate Emotion)

I thought of my title on the way home from class (pretty kicky, I know)--I couldn't stop thinking about what happened in our warm, knitted circle, wondering WHY I had the reaction I did to the question posed to me.

I am a bit of a social crier, to be sure, so Davinia's glistening eyes as she talked about her father nearly did me in.

And then Kim said something about being a mom, and this is something I never would have considered as an answer to "what's the best thing about being a woman?" just under two years ago. I probably would have said something trite, or sarcastic, or witty, as I am wont to do on many occasions. But now the idea of "mom" is one that I own, that I carry upon me so heavily and tenderly, and that idea, compounded by the prior appearance of tears...

...well, the rest is...evidence running down my face.

Why did this (the appearance of my own emotion) so startle and disorient me? For one, I think our culture shuns so-called "feminine" or emotional expressions in classes. We applaud passion, but only the type that leads to strong outbursts of argument brilliantly constructed and delivered. We cringe at the sight of tears--of, to many, a sign of weakness.

And I am equally guilty. Emotion makes me uncomfortable, especially emotion in public spaces where only public actions are desired.

But who SAID emotion of this kind is a private-space only act? Perhaps we ought to ask our culture, our society that. Why are we, feminists of all ages/faces/genders, so skeptical of everything ELSE our patriarchal society tells us but NOT THIS?

Gosh, we are so repressed. I am. I've spent all my life being bigger and braver than the bad stuff that has happened to me. And now I'm this uber-cynical woman who is terrified of someone finding out I'm not as smart or put together as I might appear. (Maybe you're already on to me.) And it's not even that it's a founded fear, but it's one that I hold.

Insecurity. Emotional baggage. Why are these the words we use for someone who feels? Why is it SO BAD?

Perhaps the nurturing side of feminist pedagogy can help us realize that it's okay to care deeply for people, and for those people to BE REAL in turn. No one is constantly calm and poised.

Why do we keep pretending?

14 October 2008

Feminist Pedagogy – A ‘slave’ morality?


I am one of those who reacts to the very mention of ‘feminism.’ It is not because I envision a ‘feminazi’ or any other scary image. In fact, I agree with many of the theory’s positions. Susan C. Jarratt tells us that feminism involves, “the decentering or sharing of authority, the recognition of students as sources of knowledge, [and] a focus on process over products.” She goes on, though, to the area of the pedagogy that I find exceedingly troublesome: “investment in a view of contemporary society as sexist and patriarchal, and of the complicity of reading, writing, and teaching in those conditions” (115). It thus defines itself as a reaction and opposition to the structure in which it works and strives to recreate the teaching process from inside of it. This posture, which I could never articulate so clearly until now, has always bothered me, and I finally understand why. It closely resembles Nietzsche’s conception of the ‘slave morality’ which he describes in Thus Spake Zarathusra:

There … is an oppressed, suffering, unemancipated, and weary one [to whom] all THAT will be held to be good [is that] which alleviates the state of suffering. Pity, the obliging hand, the warm heart, patience, industry, and humility--these are unquestionably the qualities we shall here find flooded with the light of approval and admiration; because they are the most USEFUL qualities--; … they are of assistance in the "struggle for existence" which is the motive force behind the people practicing this morality…. Strength, health, … and power are regarded with hate, suspicion, and fear by the subordinate class.

Feminists view social structures as built to suit men, and so as masculine. In the classroom, this translates to the belief that “male students gain advantages from the gender inequities built into everyday conversational practice” (119). Apparently, men tend to think and speak one way, and this is the same way of the academy. Jarratt offers Paula Treichler’s summary of a study on communication differences between genders (120), but I find that it does not represent me as a woman correctly. I wonder how many men would say that it represents them correctly.

Feminist pedagogy, as a young body of theories, is still defining itself. Because it grows out of oppression and arguably still exists within one, it very naturally adopts a ‘slave morality’-oriented perception of its situation and possible solutions, and so these are not independent, strong theories – they, like that which they fight, are born of the patriarchy. In order to develop a ‘master morality, a pedagogy that stands apart from what these pedagogues perceive as a male-centered world, they must find their own values and build from desire, and not from reaction.

Community Feminism

“Feminist Pedagogy” by Susan C. Jarratt & “Community-Service Pedagogy” by Laura Julier

Feminist Pedagogy has some interesting things to offer teachers, and several ideas stuck out to me as I read Jarratt’s essay. I thought her comment on marginalized or contingent workers composed mostly of part-time female teachers was hard to read. Mostly this is because I fall into this category. I do feel that being a part-time instructor at the postsecondary level has its drawbacks. While I am gaining valuable experience, I do not have insurance or security in my job. While teachers are needed, I can be replaced the moment I decide to take leave. I also find it interesting that composition attracts mostly white females. Why is that? What causes white females to be drawn to this profession? What causes minority teachers to be the minority? These questions would need a lot of research to even begin answering them, but are interesting views that perhaps should be explored.

Another portion of Jarrett’s essay that I found interesting was the comment “one of the strengths of feminist pedagogy is its relentless capacity for dialogue and self-critique” (117). While I understand that this is a strength, in the sense that dialogue and self-critique allows for growth and change, it also seems that critics could view this strength as a weakness. Jarratt’s word choice of ‘relentless capacity’ produces this possible negative viewpoint. These words have a negative connotation. Jarratt probably should’ve been more careful with her word choice. Another area where I question Jarratt’s word choice is on page 118. Jarratt says that “feminist pedagogy…is not about forcing all the students to subscribe to a particular political position but rather engaging with students on the terrain of language in the gendered world we all currently inhabit” (118). I’m not sure of Jarratt’s intention with stating that Feminist Pedagogy is not about forcing students to subscribe to something. It seems that most instructors who follow a pedagogy or two wouldn’t advocate forcing anything upon students. Students would probably rebel against the teacher for forcing them to subscribe to a particular set of theories.

Several things that I liked and thought were useful to teachers exploring Feminist Pedagogy for the first time were the ideas of nurturing in conjunction with composition. Seeing ways that the feminist perspective can be melded into a composition course can give teachers a way to perhaps begin to integrate this pedagogy into a personal philosophy. It is valuable to understand that the “feminist validation of personal experience” can be a useful idea in composition (Jarratt 122). This idea permits students to express themselves in their writing and thus feel comfortable (more comfortable) as a writer. Being comfortable allows students to gain confidence as a writer. Furthermore, feminists have a nurturing and caring attitude that is also compatible with composition (Jarratt 118). In addition to these ‘motherly’ qualities, Feminist Pedagogy also advocates for collaboration and revision within the writing classroom. These qualities mesh with Process and Expressive pedagogies. The last quality that is important to Feminist Pedagogy is reflection: reflection on what it means to be a woman and a teacher; reflection on the part of the students to create comfortable, understanding, and democratic contexts for class discussion; and reflection as writers, whether female or male, to become self-aware (Jarratt 119 & 121). Reflection is important in a composition classroom and reflection also meshes well with Process Pedagogy and Expressive Pedagogy.

Community-Service Pedagogy is interesting to me, but seems hard to enact in a “traditional-styled” freshman composition classroom. While Community-Service Pedagogy seems exciting because according to those that use it, it actively engages students in contemporary society; the difficulties may be tough for some teachers to overcome (Julier 133). These difficulties could be finding companies to collaborate with, building in the proper amount of reflection, or grading the pieces created for a company, rather than a classroom. Do the standards and rubrics used in a classroom transfer to a company’s expectations? How do you fit the classroom into the company and vice versa? While discussing difficulties, I am compelled to mention Stotsky’s claim that “the teaching of writing, which has ignored its ethical concerns and moral obligations other than in issues of plagiarism or discussions of logical fallacies, is integral to preparing students adequately for their roles as citizens” (Julier 134). The reason that I felt the need to mention this quote was that it makes composition teachers sound like they don’t care about producing democratic citizens (similar concerns of Critical and maybe even Cultural Pedagogies). It seems that Community-Service Pedagogy supporters want teachers to use community-service to fill this void that they feel is evident in composition classes today. Filling this large ‘void’ could be overwhelming to teachers trying to find a pedagogy to work for them. But in spite of the perceived difficulty that goes into creating a class based on this pedagogy, there are positives that stand out to me.

What I enjoyed about Community-Service Pedagogy is that it gives students a chance, a way to connect with the community and compose pieces of writing that have a real-world/business world audience. Students are encouraged to become engaged in what they create. And with reflection (reflection is important, vital to this pedagogy), students can see their growth and see the skills they gained through the community-service experience. Another positive is that students are learning skills that will (should) transfer to life beyond college. Students can also use their experiences to “join the academic conversation from a position of authority” (Woodland qtd. in Bacon qtd. in Julier 141). As teachers all the positives of this pedagogy seem wonderful and something that teachers aim to teach their students. Now the question becomes, how can I use some of these ideas in my own teaching?

Feminist Pedagogy and Dichotomous Thinking

Feminist Pedagogy (Susan C. Jarratt)

A common thread I see running through cultural studies, critical pedagogy and feminist pedagogy is the goal of engaging students in the analysis of inequalities in power structures of dominant society. At the heart of these pedagogies is a focus on the development of the skills needed to recognize, question, and resist these inequalities. Feminist pedagogy takes this a step further with its focus on “contemporary society as sexist and patriarchal” (Jarrett, 115).

Given this, it is acknowledged that “there is a current, widely shared negative attitude about feminism in the United States” (125). Further, if we wish to engage in feminist pedagogical practices in the classroom we are warned that,” it’s good to have some advance notice about what to expect from students and to develop strategies for encountering the resistance so many offer even to the very word itself” (125). Anecdotal evidence confirming the above is easy to gather. Just mention the word feminist in some circles and watch the direction and tone of the follow-on conversation.

This leaves me wondering why there is such resistance to discussions about women's roles. While I’m sure there are many causes, some research led me to a paper titled “Unmasking Moral Dichotomies: Can Feminist Pedagogy Overcome Student Resistance?” Linda Markowitz, the author and a feminist pedagogue, discusses a study she conducted to learn how often students use “morally dichotomous frameworks to understand conflict” (Markowitz, 40). She also wanted to “determine whether exposure to feminist pedagogy during the semester might create less student resistance to discussions of oppression, difference or inequality” (40).

Markowitz's study indicates that resistance to analytic discussions of oppression, difference or inequality is based on a pre-shaped belief system that imposes dichotomous thinking. Dichotomous thinking has roots in positivist science and the belief that truth is perceived only from what we can observe and measure. This truth asks us to judge knowledge as right/wrong, good/bad, objective/subjective and so forth. It is within the framework of this system that challenges to norms, such as woman's role in society, is perceived as a threat by students.

This belief system is evident when the feminist instructor initiates a discussion about gender in relation to power and inequality and is met by students’ resistance to engage in analysis and students frame the discussion in dichotomous terms such as, “society is the blame for women having less power”, or “it’s all the fault of men”. Markowitz offers that “before we can reduce students’ perceived threats that we need to expand their morally dichotomous frameworks” (40). She proposes that feminine pedagogy practices such as “socially-contextualizing knowledge claims, participatory learning and valuing personal knowledge” (40) can help students become more willing to participate in analytical discussions of oppression, difference or inequality and its causes.

Markowitz, Linda. “Unmaking Moral Dichotomies: Can Feminist Pedagogy Overcome Student Resistance?” Gender and Education. Vol. 17, No. 1, March 2005, pp 39-55.